Free
Navigating the Nexus: Black and Brown Boys and Their Experience in Education
Navigating the Nexus: Black and Brown Boys and Their Experience in Education
First, I extend my deepest gratitude to God for granting me life and the opportunity to pursue my dreams and achieve my goals.
To my son, the driving force behind my striving to be a better man, I am profoundly thankful. You embody all that is good in me, free from my flaws. Your love and pride in calling me 'Dad' are my greatest joys.
I am deeply grateful to my family and friends for their unwavering support and for keeping me focused on this journey. Your presence has been a cornerstone of my strength and determination.
To the inspiring young men and women, I have the privilege of serving in the Appleton School District: your enthusiasm and potential continually propel me forward in my profession. Thank you for being such remarkable future leaders.
My heartfelt appreciation goes to Alverno College, the Theta Cohort, my dissertation advisor Dr. Kirk, and my esteemed professors, Dr. Bonds, Dr. Stolen, and Dr. Pointer-Mace. Your guidance and wisdom have been invaluable on this academic journey.
Lastly, I acknowledge and thank myself for having the courage to take this significant step. I am proud of dedicating the time and effort to achieve the goals I have set, always trusting in God's perfect timing and will.
The overrepresentation of Black and Brown boys in the criminal justice system is a very complex approach with many contributing factors. The deep historical roots are perpetuated by various immediate forces, all with a dire need for reform. The research I will present is based on data that has been uncovered by a disturbing trend where Black individuals are systematically portrayed as being pushed more toward criminal behavior. The bias I have taken into account has driven the growth of the American prison system, the implementation of harsh sentencing practices, capital punishment decisions, and the widespread acceptance of racial profiling (Hinton & Cook, p 269, 2021). A crucial aspect that contributes to the placement of Black and Brown boys into the criminal justice system is the infamous school-to-prison pipeline. The system is perpetuated by schools with very strict rules that disproportionately affect these students, just adding to an already unjust situation. These rules seem to penalize minor infractions, which may lead to increased involvement within the criminal justice system, rather than provide the necessary support within the K-12 educational system setting for our Black and Brown boys. Since the inception of modern policing, local law enforcement has often labeled Black and Brown boys as aggressive and views them as enemies, framing them as potential threats to state authority and social order (Hinton & Cook, p 263, 2021). This perception has contributed to the disproportionate arrest and incarceration rates within African-American communities and has created a "statistical discourse" that reinforces stereotypes of Black criminality in both popular and political discourse (Hinton & Cook, p 269, 2021).
The current state of the issue you are proposing to address
My dissertation seeks to address these pressing issues, not only by looking into the underlying research and theories but also maybe potential solutions. By studying the impact of discipline policies on Black and Brown boys, research aims to identify the systemic problems and recommend equitable solutions. In my dissertation, I will search the historical context, cultural influences, and the mechanics of educational disparities affecting Black and Brown boys in their educational experiences. I will also examine the effect of discipline policies on their educational journey and life trajectory. The approach will use a wide range of sources, including expert research, interviews that will investigate the real life educational experiences of former and current incarcerated Black and Brown boys, to provide a holistic view of the situation.
Anticipated impact of your proposed research
Ultimately, my goal is to propose better restorative practices and communication approaches that can narrow the achievement gap, dismantle the school-to-prison pipeline, and provide Black and Brown boys with a great educational experience. To contribute to the ongoing dialogue regarding educational disparities and the rules that preserve them. I aim to have a fairer and more inclusive K-12 educational system that empowers not just Black and Brown boys, but all students, regardless of their background, to achieve their full potential.
Problem Statement
The education system in America combats a deeply ingrained and troubling issue: the unequal impact of discipline policies on Black and Brown boys. Overwhelming evidence reveals that these students face a disproportionately high rate of disciplinary actions, such as suspensions, expulsions, and office referrals that lead to interactions with law enforcement, in comparison to their white peers. For example, based on OCR data from every state, 28 percent of Black males in middle school were suspended, compared to just 10 percent of White males.(Losen, 2023)
The report's further analysis of data for 18 of the nation's largest districts found that in 15 of them, at least 30 percent of all enrolled Black males were suspended one or more times. Across these 18 urban districts, hundreds of individual schools had extraordinarily high suspension rates--50 percent or higher for Black males..(Losen, 2023)
Purpose Statement
My dissertation seeks to address these pressing issues, not only by looking into the underlying research and theories but also maybe potential solutions. By studying the impact of discipline policies on Black and Brown boys, research aims to identify systemic problems and recommend equitable solutions.
Racial Disparities in Disciplinary Actions
Racial Discipline Gap and School Suspensions
School-to-Prison Pipeline
Historical Context and Systemic Deficiencies
References
Losen, Daniel J. “Discipline Policies, Successful Schools, Racial Justice, and the Law.” Race, Racism and the Law, 19 Oct. 2023,
Hinton, Elizabeth, and DeAnza Cook. “The Mass Criminalization of Black Americans: A Historical Overview.” Annual Review of Criminology, vol. 4, no. 1, Jan. 2021, pp. 261–86. DOI.org (Crossref), https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-criminol-060520-033306.
Doctoral Student Alverno College
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.